Lowtax: Global Tax and Business Portal










Ethical Moonshine

13 June 2010

Nearly half of the British public says it's interested in finding out about the ethical credentials of the next financial product or service that they buy, according to a recent poll. Or so they say. It's like that old question: "Have you stopped beating your wife yet?" Of course I am interested in saving the planet, I will say in answer to the pollster's question. In a way it's surprising that only half the people agreed; do the other half agree with me then that 'ethical investment' is for the birds?

First of all, it doesn't work in investment terms. I have never seen a survey which claimed higher returns for ethical investment than . . er . . . what is the opposite of ethical investment? . . . unethical investment? That's what the moral majority, or as it seems the moral plurality, would like us to call it, perhaps.

A better distinction would be between 'productive' investment and 'non-productive' investment, the former being investment which tends to increase the goods which result, including employment and consumption, while the latter is investment into passive assets such as gold or antique motor cars, which have little or no effect on the human condition.

Let's take vodka production as being presumably a prime 'unethical' activity. The Russian government has just announced a swingeing increase in the tax on vodka, with the professed aim of cutting down on drunkenness, which certainly is a scourge in Russia, and always has been. 'Ethical' investors will nod their heads in approval, and hope to see the shares of Brown-Forman (NYSE-listed owner of Finlandia, the leading imported vodka brand) fall. And what will be the results of this 'ethical' crusade?

For the little old ladies who own shares in Brown-Forman, it will mean loss of income and wealth; for the Finnish employees of Finlandia it will mean loss of jobs and concomitant tax increases to pay for their unemployment benefit; for Russian vodka drinkers it will mean a flight to cheaper brands and an increase in the illicit production of vodka, which already supplies 42% of the market according to the Russian government's own statistics, and killed 35,000 people last year.

Attacking the producers of 'unethical' goods such as tobacco, alcohol, guns and dynamite will never be very successful because these goods cater to basic aspects of human nature. If you stop Brown Forman from supplying vodka to Russia by starving it of investment, you will simply hand the market to a Polish or Chinese competitor.

What will work is to create an educated middle class in Russia which prefers to drink Moldovan champanska and has enough money not to want to buy moonshine, and to help countries where child labour is prevalent to climb the economic ladder to a point at which parents can afford to send their children to school rather than to the tobacco plantation.

Railing against the suppliers of 'unethical' goods and starving them of resources are lazy and ineffectual armchair responses to real, existential problems which have real solutions. But if your life-style doesn't permit you to throw up your job and join Voluntary Service Overseas, at least you have the comfort of knowing that your conspicuous consumption is fuelling economic growth in some God-forsaken territory whose name you don't even know.

You have been reading an entry on the following blog:

Penelope Wise

Penny Wise but not Pound Foolish! But remember: I am not offering investment advice. My comments are just for your general information; I do not recommend investments, and you should take professional advice before entering any investment contract.
Penelope blogs on investment and financial services around the world: mainstream and alternative. Contact: penny@lowtax.net



Tags: Hong Kong | Investment | Offshore | Taxation


More posts from Penelope Wise

Goodbye To Blighty?

Not Another Wretched Pin-Code To Remember!

Ethical Moonshine

Shall We Take A Glass Together?

A Walk In The Forest

No Pensions, Please, We're British

The Ex-Wives' Charter, Norwegian Style

To Will Or Not To Will?

Time To Get Out Of Money?

There's No Fool Like A Gold Fool

Please Securitize Me

Is Oil Cheap?

Thank You, Mr Paulson

Alphabet Soup

Don't Play Poker With Uncle Sam

Please Turn Out The Lights As You Leave

How To Learn To Love Accounting Standards

Caveat Emptor?

No More Fat Cat Investments For Me!

To Buy Or Not To Buy?

Don't Have A Foreign Boy-Friend!

Never Trust Your Money To A Nation State

Good Advice From Adam Smith For Gordon In His New Home

Beards Can Make You Rich

Financial Regulators To Create Global Anti-Investor Cartel

Goodbye, Gordon!

Auntie Brussels Wants To Know About Your Money

Governments Fail Business One More Time


Interested in blogging on Lowtax? We are currently accepting submissions!

By hosting your blog on the network you or your company can expect to benefit from our very high traffic levels. We boast one of the largest communities of professionals (tax, offshore, legal, etc) and HNWIs. If you are already a blogger, but want a wider audience, you can move an existing blog to our network, or if you've never blogged before, why not have a go? We'll help you get started.

E-mail blogs@lowtax.net to learn more.




Lowtax Forums More
 Austria 2 Topics
 Monaco 1 Topics
 Andorra 21 Topics
 Botswana 2 Topics
 St Vincent & the Grenadines 1 Topics
 Hong Kong 21 Topics
 Germany 3 Topics
 Cayman Islands 8 Topics
 Offshore Trusts Guide 2 Topics
 Asia/Pacific No topics yet
 Cook Islands 2 Topics
 India No topics yet
 Investors Offshore 16 Topics
 Marshall Islands 2 Topics
 Liechtenstein 4 Topics
 Gibraltar 3 Topics
 Malta 13 Topics
 China No topics yet
 Barbados 4 Topics
 Estonia 1 Topics
 

Network Tweets


Strategic Partners

Lowtax Network Portal: 'Low-tax' business and investment in the top 50 jurisdictions covered in exceptional detail.
Tax News
: Global tax news, continuously updated through the day.
Investors Offshore: The independent offshore and alternative investment guide for expatriates and the globally aware investor.
Law & Tax News: Daily news and background data on tax and legal developments for international business.
Offshore-e-com: A topical guide to offshore e-commerce focused on tax and regulation.
Lowtax Library: One of the web's largest and most authoritative business and investment information sources.
US Tax Network: The resource for free online US taxation information, covering: corporate tax, individual tax, international tax, expatriates, sales and e-commerce tax, investment tax.
Personal Business Tax Guide: Providing essential tax news and information on business for contractors, entrepreneurs, professionals, small businesses, artists, sportspersons and entertainers.
Offshore Trusts Guide: OTG publishes news, features and newsletters on the use of offshore trust structures.
TreatyPro: The online tax treaty resource.


Lowtax Library

One of the web's largest and most authoritative business and investment information sources. Alongside topical, daily news on worldwide tax developments, you can receive weekly newswires or access up-to-date intelligence reports on a range of legal, tax and investment subjects.

FREE TRIAL NEWS SUBSCRIPTION

Our 16 constantly updated intelligence reports cover every important aspect of 'offshore' and international tax-planning in depth, including banking secrecy, the EU's savings tax directive, offshore funds, e-commerce, offshore gaming and transfer pricing. Reports are available for immediate downloading or as subscription services with news pages.


Advertising & Marketing

With over 50,000 qualified readers every month our web-sites offer a number of cost effective, targeted advertising, sponsorship and marketing opportunities:

- Display advertising - from 'skyscrapers' to 'buttons'
- Content/article submission and sponsorship
- Opt-in email marketing
- On-line Services Directory listings

Click here to learn more or contact Charles Bell on +44 (0)1424 205 425 or at charles@bsi-media.com and he will put you in touch with your regional rep.


News & Content Solutions

Could your corporate web-site or newsletter benefit from incorporating regularly updated news and content tailored to serve your clients' interests? We can provide a variety of maintenance-free news and content solutions that can be seamlessly integrated and dynamically delivered:

- Customised, personalised 'own-brand' news services
- Newsletter content and management
- News Headline Tickers

Click here to learn more or contact Charles Bell on +44 (0)1424 205 425 or at charles@bsi-media.com and he will put you in touch with your regional rep.